South Carolina Environmental Law Project

Lawyers for the Wild Side of South Carolina


SC Coastal Municipalities and Small Business Chamber Celebrate Seismic Lawsuit Win

SC Coastal Municipalities and Small Business Chamber Celebrate Seismic Lawsuit Win

Judge dismisses case on mootness grounds since seismic surveying cannot occur without contested authorizations.

CHARLESTON, S.C. – U.S. District Judge Richard Gergel of South Carolina issued a Rubin Order, or a conditional dismissal, of the federal seismic litigation following a concession from the Federal Defendants that the Incidental Harassment Authorizations (IHAs) allowing seismic blasting in the Atlantic will expire at the end of November and cannot be extended, renewed or reissued, and a concession from the seismic companies that they cannot begin surverying prior to the expiration.

As a result of these admissions, the five companies granted these permissions would have to completely restart the months-long permit application process, including the opportunity for public notice and comment.

Today’s decision is a major victory for the 16 coastal municipalities and the South Carolina Small Business Chamber of Commerce that challenged these IHAs that the National Marine Fisheries Service issued to the companies.

These IHAs would have allowed the companies to harass scores of marine life during seismic airgun blasting, a process that involves extremely loud, continuous blasts of acoustic pulses to map oil and gas deposits along the ocean floor.

“Preventing this harmful activity is a resounding victory for nearly every form of marine life, from phytoplankton at the base of the food chain to the endangered right whale, which would be harassed, injured or killed by seismic air gun blasting,” said Amy Armstrong, Executive Director of the South Carolina Environmental Law Project (SCELP), “but we must remain vigilant and continue fighting to protect our coastal environment.”

SCELP, a nonprofit environmental law organization, filed the federal lawsuit on behalf of the Small Business Chamber and the municipalities challenging the harms that seismic would cause to the state’s environment and coastal economy.

Frank Knapp Jr., the President & CEO of the Small Business Chamber said, “We have won this battle to protect the Atlantic but not the war. I believe that if Mr. Trump is re-elected he will rescind this Executive Order on a drilling moratorium, new seismic permit applications will be submitted immediately, and the Bureau of Ocean Energy Management will put the Atlantic in the next 5 year leasing plan that starts in 2022. Only a new Congress passing a bill and a new President signing it to ban offshore drilling in the Atlantic will win the war.”

Along with the Small Business Chamber, the 16 coastal municipalities named in suit include Beaufort, Charleston, Folly Beach, Isle of Palms, North Myrtle Beach, Bluffton, Briarcliffe Acres, Edisto Beach, Hilton Head Island, James Island, Kiawah Island, Mount Pleasant, Pawleys Island, Port Royal, Seabrook Island and Awendaw.

Quotes from municipalities:

“Winning a battle is clearly a win, and we appreciate the grassroots support and tenacious legal counsel. Rather than basking in victory, however, we must diligently continue our aggressive pursuit to permanently end seismic testing and drilling until the Congress and the Administration codify the elimination of dangerous seismic testing and drilling off our pristine coast. The House passed a measure that appears hidden in the U.S. Senate. Executive Orders come and go with the strike of a pen. Laws are what we need. Now is not the time to rest on our laurels, but a time to press on until there is a final solution, We still have a tall mountain to climb to bring an end to this nonsense,” according to Billy Keyserling, Mayor of City of Beaufort which was the first city in South Carolina to initiative petitions to the government several years ago.

“This decision is good news for Charleston and good news for the state of South Carolina. Seismic testing simply cannot be allowed to happen off our coast. Our quality of life and the livelihoods of too many of our citizens rely on a clean, healthy ocean habitat,” Charleston Mayor John Tecklenburg said.

Seabrook Island Mayor John Gregg cheered today’s ruling. “Dismissal is indeed good news for South Carolina’s coastal communities and the Town of Seabrook Island as seismic testing is off the table for now and into the foreseeable future. We thank SCELP for being such an effective advocate for us in our efforts to protect our coastal resources.”

“This is very good news!” said North Myrtle Beach Mayor Marilyn Hatley. “Our beautiful environment, which is also of utmost important to our tourism industry, remains protected for a while longer. Together with other coastal jurisdictions, we will continue to monitor any future efforts pertaining to offshore drilling and, if challenged again, we will fight the good fight again.”

Folly Beach Mayor Tim Goodwin said, “Stopping offshore drilling along the coast is vital to protect South Carolina’s beaches. Our beaches are a precious natural resource that provide habitat for several endangered species. They are also the foundation of a tourism economy that brings in over $20 billion dollars annually to our State. The outcome of this lawsuit is an important step, but we look forward to securing a permanent ban, backed by the Federal government. I am eager to work with our Congressional Representatives and Senators on this issue in the future.”

“We are pleased to learn of this victory. Protecting our coastal environment from all harm is critical for survival of all marine life and our overall quality of life. We are all connected to the ocean by virtue of living here and to see that connection obliterated would have been devastating to this community. This victory ensures the long-term vitality of our coastal waters for every creature that depends on it and for future generations to enjoy,” said Hilton Head Island Mayor John McCann.

“The court ruling regarding seismic testing is to be celebrated as a victory for our coastal South Carolina and the people of our state. While we can rejoice in this decision to protects our environment for the short term, let us remain vigilant in the future in case of any renewal of testing and drilling efforts,” said Jane Darby, Mayor of the Town of Edisto Beach.

Media contact:
Amy Armstrong, Esquire, [email protected]
South Carolina Environmental Law Project, (843) 527-0078

South Carolina Environmental Law Project is a nonprofit public interest law firm. Its mission is to protect the natural environment of South Carolina by providing legal services and advice to environmental organizations and concerned citizens and by improving the state’s system of environmental regulation.

Download available Seismic Rubin Order

Posted: Oct 6, 2020 | Page link

Long Savannah Project Would Destroy 209 Acres of Wetlands in Flood-Prone West Ashley
Posted: Jul 30, 2020
Sierra Club files lawsuit over expired permits at three South Carolina coal plants
Posted: Jul 9, 2020
Conservationists Move to Join Suit to Support City in Addressing Flooding
Posted: Jul 7, 2020
Take a Tour of Charleston's Waterways (and Learn Why We Must Protect Them!)
Posted: Jun 29, 2020
Settlement Reached to Protect Endangered Species
Posted: Jun 23, 2020
Conservation Groups Step Up Against Massive Charleston County Residential Project
Posted: Jun 5, 2020
Rural Landowners Appeal Greenville County’s Approval of Subdivision in Blue Ridge
Posted: Jun 1, 2020
Advocates Propose to Intervene in Effort to Revise Jurisdictional Lines on Captain Sams Spit
Posted: May 26, 2020
Download a Free Copy of Our Shoreline Issues Brochure
Posted: May 14, 2020
Concerned Citizens Initiate ESA Legal Process Over Proposed Dollar General
Posted: May 8, 2020
Clean Water Act Lawsuit Launched Against Pickens County Event Venue
Posted: Apr 7, 2020
Gullah/Geechee Group Files Motion Against Bay Point Destruction
Posted: Feb 24, 2020
SC Supreme Court Reverses and Remands Union Pier Cruise Ship Terminal Case
Posted: Feb 19, 2020
Pickens County and its Residents Win Appeal Over Coal Ash Landfill
Posted: Jan 8, 2020
Beaufort County Rejects Bay Point Island Development Proposal
Posted: Dec 20, 2019
Demanding Action on Expired Permits for Coal-Fired Power Plants
Posted: Dec 3, 2019
Legal Challenge Against Hilton Head Seawall Aims to Protect Public Beach
Posted: Nov 20, 2019
Groups File 60-Day Notice of Clean Water Act Lawsuit Against Event Venue Over Massive Sediment Discharges into Pristine Waters
Posted: Nov 14, 2019
The Bramlett Plant is Leaking Dangerous Pollutants Into Reedy River, Immediate Cleanup Needed
Posted: Nov 5, 2019
Administrative Law Court denies request to proceed with groin construction on Debidue in Georgetown County
Posted: Aug 29, 2019
SCDHEC Asked to Revisit 2015 Decisions to Approve Seismic Testing Permits 
Posted: Aug 6, 2019
DHEC Responds to Push to Raise Water Quality Standard
Posted: Jul 11, 2019
16 Coastal Communities and Small Businesses Implore DHEC to Oppose Seismic Blasting
Posted: Jul 1, 2019
Petition Aims to Improve SC Recreational Water Quality Standards
Posted: Jun 25, 2019
Ingram Dunes Case Dropped After City Closes on Purchase
Posted: Jun 19, 2019
Furman Students Call on Greenville Mayor to Clean Coal Tar Pit
Posted: Apr 17, 2019
SCELP Praises Removal of Illegally Constructed Litchfield Seawalls
Posted: Apr 17, 2019
Groups challenge proposed groins on Georgetown Co. beach, efforts to engineer shoreline
Posted: Apr 10, 2019
SC’s Highest Court Forces Changes at Radioactive Barnwell Landfill
Posted: Mar 27, 2019
Development Plans Threaten Sensitive Pocotaligo River and Sands Beach
Posted: Mar 26, 2019
Legal Action Needed to Save Ingram Dunes
Posted: Mar 25, 2019
16 Coastal Cities, Small Businesses Double Down on Fight to Block Seismic Blasting
Posted: Feb 28, 2019
Federal Judge Orders Trump Administration to Stop Taking Action on Seismic Permitting Pending Government Shutdown
Posted: Jan 18, 2019
2019 Legislative Session Kicks Off
Posted: Jan 9, 2019
Fishing Creek Quarry Plans Thwarted!
Posted: Dec 13, 2018
Florence, the Environment and Accountability
Posted: Oct 12, 2018
Beached Houses Is What You Get
Posted: Oct 10, 2018
Stinking Up the Beach, 'till It Lasts
Posted: Oct 10, 2018
Administrative Law Judge OKs Captain Sams Spit Development for the Third Time
Posted: Sep 25, 2018
Private Property vs Public Beach
Posted: Aug 8, 2018
Slow but steady progress on the Reedy River
Posted: Jul 27, 2018
The Summer Newsletter is Here!
Posted: Jul 19, 2018
Massive Proposed Limestone Mine Threatening Local Community in Williamsburg County
Posted: Jul 3, 2018
Fishing Creek Heelsplitter Population At Risk
Posted: Jun 7, 2018
Good Compromise on Hunting Island
Posted: May 11, 2018
Big Win on Captain Sams Spit. Third Time's the Charm?
Posted: Apr 18, 2018
We Must Preserve Coastal Carolina's Highest Sand Dunes
Posted: Apr 4, 2018
Automatic Stay Critically Wounded
Posted: Mar 8, 2018
Seismic Challenge is Ramping Up
Posted: Feb 8, 2018
The Winter Newsletter Is Here!
Posted: Jan 13, 2018
Access to Coastal Islands - A Regulatory Success
Posted: Dec 20, 2017
Groins - Hitting Close to Home
Posted: Dec 13, 2017
South Carolina Hazardous Waste War
Posted: Dec 6, 2017
Another Win around Captain Sams Spit, but the Developers Do not Relent
Posted: Oct 5, 2017
Opposing a 1,000-acre Gamble on the Sampit
Posted: Sep 25, 2017
Chronicle of the Most Recent, 7-day Trial to Save the Spit
Posted: Sep 8, 2017
Pawleys Island Groin Permit, Denied!
Posted: Aug 4, 2017
SC Supreme Court Will Rehear Our Public Trust Case
Posted: Aug 4, 2017
Engaging the Reedy's Forgotten Contamination Corridor
Posted: Jul 3, 2017
The Summer Newsletter is Here!
Posted: Jul 3, 2017
Business Alliance Stands Against Seismic Blasts in the Atlantic
Posted: May 2, 2017
Trump Re-Opens the Atlantic to Offshore Drilling
Posted: Apr 26, 2017
Challenging the Dominion Pipeline
Posted: Apr 5, 2017
New Skirmishes on Captain Sams Spit
Posted: Apr 5, 2017
Court of Appeals Upholds Agreement to Protect Wetlands in Pawleys Island
Posted: Mar 23, 2017
What Is Happening with the Pinewood Site?
Posted: Mar 1, 2017
Automatic Stay Attacks Threaten Your Due Process Rights
Posted: Mar 1, 2017
The Winter Newsletter Is Here!
Posted: Jan 20, 2017
Seismic Victory! It's Time to Celebrate
Posted: Jan 20, 2017
Upstate Office Opens!
Posted: Oct 6, 2016
ALC Judge Puts Captain Sams Spit Back in Jeopardy
Posted: Mar 31, 2016
Tensions Remain High in our Bays & Bears Case
Posted: Feb 18, 2016
The Heat is On against False Crawls and Plastic Walls
Posted: Feb 10, 2016
Lowcountry Giving Day a Win for the Wild Side!
Posted: Apr 28, 2015
Serious Consideration of Impacts Needed in Applications for Seismic Testing in SC
Posted: Mar 4, 2015
SCELP Director to Take Home the Silver
Posted: Feb 19, 2015
Black Bear Habitat Threatened
Posted: Jan 27, 2015
Pappa's Island is Preserved!
Posted: Dec 17, 2014
Oakridge Landfill Threatens Four Holes Swamp
Posted: Dec 17, 2014
Landmark Ruling Protects Captains Sams Spit
Posted: Dec 17, 2014
Double Your Donation with Donnelley!
Posted: Sep 3, 2014
SCELP Staunches Flow of Radioactive Waste into Groundwater
Posted: Jul 31, 2014
Opponents win round over developing Kiawah Island's Capt. Sams Spit but impact debated
Posted: Jun 18, 2014
SCELP continues to work to defend the integrity of SC's Beachfront Management Act
Posted: May 23, 2014
SCELP Board Members Frances Close & Paula Feldman spoke, among others, at a press conference in opposition to the bill destroying SC's beachfront management protections
Posted: May 23, 2014
SCELP's Amy Armstrong sworn in as municipal judge
Posted: May 23, 2014
Second Annual Midlands Celebration
Posted: May 5, 2014
SCELP filed an appeal of judge's ruling over Charleston cruise terminal on behalf of community groups
Posted: Apr 23, 2014
Mingo Point, Kiawah Island kayak and boat excursion
Posted: Apr 16, 2014
Victory in Laurens County
Posted: Apr 7, 2014
SCELP is working to defend the integrity of SC's Beachfront Management Act
Posted: Apr 2, 2014
SCELP Secures Settlement to Protect Angel Oak
Posted: Jan 31, 2014
SCELP Lawyers Complete Trial in Kiawah Land Dispute
Posted: Jan 31, 2014
Supreme Court Agrees to Hearing EAGLE Landfill Case
Posted: Jul 1, 2013
Pawleys Island Groin Fight Heats Up
Posted: Jul 1, 2013
Supreme Court Rehears Captain Sams Case a Third Time
Posted: Mar 28, 2013
Dr. Angela Halfacre to Speak About Her Book, "A Delicate Balance: Constructing a Conservation Culture of the S.C. Lowcountry"
Posted: Jul 5, 2012
The State Newspaper covers the last day of our Angel Oak trial
Posted: Apr 6, 2012
Famed Angel Oak threatened, judge told
Posted: Apr 4, 2012
Marlboro in fierce fight against landfill
Posted: Apr 1, 2012
Walter Edgar's Journal - SCETV - Interview with Amy Armstrong
Posted: Jan 25, 2012